| I. |
Cognitive Processes. |
| |
|
|
| |
A. |
Cognitive Task
Analysis
Aptima’s CTA Resource
Web Site. A comprehensive resource for CTA techniques. Highlights
includes a library of CTA papers, a table of CTA methods,
regular online seminars given by leaders in the field, and a CTA
e-Magazine.
Alm, I. Cognitive Tasks: A Meta Analysis of Methods.
FOA Report No C 500985.5, Sundbyberg, Sweden, National Defense
Research Establishment, Department of Human Studies (1992).
Describes GEMS and HTA in some detail.
Chipman, Shalin & Schraagen, Eds. Cognitive Task
Analysis. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000. A compilation
of papers on many CTA methods by leaders in the field.
Merkelbach, E. J. H. M. & Schraagen, J. M. C. A
Framework for the Analysis of Cognitive Tasks. TNO Human
Factors Research Institute, Report No TNO-TM 1994 B-13 (1994).
Describes a framework for conducting CTA using a combination of
Hierarchical Task Analysis (HTA), Knowledge Analysis and
Documentation System (KADS), and GOMS.
Gordon, S. E. & Gill, R. T. Cognitive Task Analysis. In
C.E. Zsambok & G. Klein, Eds. Naturalistic Decision
Making. Mahway, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1997. 131-140.
Provides an overview of CTA techniques, with brief descriptions
of Concept Mapping, COGNET, Conceptual Graph Analysis, and PARI.
Gordan, T. R., Coovert, M. D., Riddle, D. L, & Miles, D. E. "Classifying C2 Decision Making
Jobs Using Cognitive Task Analysis and Verbal Protocol
Analysis." In Proceedings of the 6th International
Command and Control Research Technology Symposium (2001).
CTA and verbal protocol analysis are used to analyze AWACS
Weapons Director teams. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
1. |
Applied Cognitive Task Analysis (ACTA)
Klein Associates Home Page.
A company founded by naturalistic decision making guru Gary
Klein. Has information on ACTA, ACTA software, ACTA training
courses, the Critical Decision Method, and studies of
naturalistic decision making.
Davison, H. Cognitive Task Analysis: Current
Research. Power Point Presentation (46 slides).
Provides an overview of cognitive task analysis techniques,
focusing specifically on ACTA and HTA. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Eddy, M.F., Kribs, H.D., & Cowen, M.B. Cognitive and
Behavioral Task Implications for Three-Dimensional Displays Used in
Combat Information/Direction Centers. SPAWAR Systems
Center, Technical Report 1792 (1999). ACTA is used to
determine whether tactical information should be displayed in 3D to
improve battlespace situation awareness. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Hardinge, N. Cognitive Task Analysis of Decision
Strategies of Submarine Sonar and Target Motion Analysis
Operators: Phase 1. Office of Naval Research, Final
Technical Report, Contract No. N00014-99-1044 (2000). The ACTA
method is applied to the analysis of decision strategies of
submarine sonar and target motion analysts.
[View or Download: Local
Copy]
Militello, L. G. & Hutton, R. J.B. "Applied
Cognitive Task Analysis (ACTA): A Practitioner's Toolkit for
Understanding Cognitive Task Demands." Ergonomics
Vol 41.11 (1998): 1618-1641. A fairly detailed description of
the ACTA method. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Militello, L. G., Hutton, R. J. B., Pliske, R. M., Knight,
B. J., & Klein, G. Applied Cognitive Task Analysis
(ACTA)
Methodology. Navy Personnel Research and Development
Center (1997). A detailed description of how to conduct the
ACTA method. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Miller, T. E., Copeland, R. R., Phillips, Jennifer K.,
& McCloskey, M. J. A Cognitive Approach to Developing
Planning Tools to Support Air Campaign Planners. Air Force
Research Laboratory, Information Directorate. Rome, NY (August
1999). The ACTA method and the Critical Decision Method are
used to capture strategies and tactical concerns of air
campaign planners for use in the development of a software
decision support tool. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Phillips, J., McDermott, P. L., Thordsen, M., McCloskey,
M., & Klein, G. Cognitive Requirements for Small Unit
Leaders in Military Operations in Urban Terrain. U.S. Army
Research Institute for the Behavorial and Social Sciences,
Research Report 1728 (1998). An ACTA of platoon leaders of
MOUT (Military Operations in Urban Terrain) operations is
conducted and used to guide the development of a
scenario-based training program. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
2. |
The Critical Decision Method (CDM)
Freeman, J. T. & Cohen, M. S. A Critical Decision
Analysis of Aspects of Naval Anti-Air Warfare. Cognitive
Technologies, Inc., Technical Report 98-2 (1998). The CDM is
used to analyze naval anti-air warfare, air strike warfare,
and theater ballistic missile defense. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Grassi, C. R. A Task Analysis of Peir Side Ship-Handling
for Virtual Environment Ship-Handling Simulator Scenario
Development. Master's Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School.
Monterey, CA (September 2000). The CDM is used with GOMS and
portions of the ACTA method to develop training scenarios for
use in a ship-handling simulator. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Hoffman, R. R., Crandall, B., & Shadbolt, N. "Use
of the Critical Decision Method to Elicit Expert Knowledge: A
Case Study in the Methodology of Cognitive Task
Analysis." Human Factors Vol 40.2 (1998): 254-276.
Detailed description of the CDM.
Klein, G. A. The Development of Knowledge Elicitation
Methods for Capturing Military Expertise. U. S. Army
Research Institute for the Behavioral and Social Sciences
(1996). Presents a number of studies conducted using the CDM,
as well as a formal rationale, description, and set of
guidelines for conducting the CDM. [View or
Download: Local
Copy]
Klein, G. A., Calderwood, R., & MacGregor, D.
"Critical Decision Method for Eliciting Knowledge."
IEEE
Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics Vol. 19.3
(1989). A detailed description of the CDM.
MacMillan, J., Sefarty, D., Cohen, M., Freeman, J., Klein,
G., & Thordsen, M. Critical Decisions in the Advanced
Multimodal Watchstation Air Dominance Scenario. U.S. Air
Force Research Laboratory (2000). The CDM is used to analyze
decision making in an air dominance scenario. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Miletello, L. Qualitative Research Methods for
Investigation of Adverse Events and Near Misses. Power
Point Briefing (23 slides).
An overview of the CDM. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Thorsden, M. "A comparison of two tools for cognitive
task analysis: Concept mapping and the critical decision
method." In Proceedings of the Human Factors and
Ergonomics Society 35th Annual Meeting (1991).
Concept mapping and the critical decision method are compared.
|
| |
|
3. |
PARI Method (Precursor (reason for
action), Action, Result, Interpretation (of result))
Marsh, C. "The F-16 Maintenance Skills Tutor."
The
Edge: MITRE's Advanced Technology Newsletter Vol 3.1
(1999). The PARI method is used to inform the design of an
F-16 maintenance skills tutor. [View or Download: From
Source]
Gott, S. P. Rediscovering Learning: Acquiring
Expertise in Real World Problem Solving Tasks. Armstrong
Research Laboratory, Report Number AL/HR-TP-1997-0009, Brooks
AFB, Texas: April 1998. Results from the PARI method are used
to inform a coached apprenticeship practice environment
embodied in an intelligent tutor. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Hall, E. P., Gott, S. P., & Pokorny, R. A. A
Procedural Guide to Cognitive Task Analysis: The PARI
Methodology. Armstrong Research Laboratory, Brooks AFB,
Texas (1995). A detailed description of how to conduct the
PARI method.
|
| |
|
4. |
Skill-Based CTA Framework
Redding, R. E. A Standard Procedure for Conducting
Cognitive Task Analysis. ERIC Document Reproduction
Service (1992). An overview of the skill-based CTA framework.
Redding, R. E., Cannon, J. R., Lierman, B. C., Ryder, J.
M., Purcell, J. A., & Seamster, T. L. "The Analysis
of Expert Performance in the Redesign of the En Route Air
Traffic Control Curriculum." In Proceedings of the
Human Factors Society 35th Annual Meeting (1991). The
skill-based CTA framework is used to inform a COGNET model of
an air traffic control task. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Seamster, T. L., Redding, R. E., & Kaempf, G. L. Applied
Cognitive Task Analysis in Aviation. Avebury, 1997. The
skill-based CTA framework is applied to design and training
problems in the commercial aviation domain.
Seamster, T. L., Redding, R. E., & Kaempf, G. L. A
Skill-Based Cognitive Task Analysis Framework. In Chipman,
Shalin & Schraagen, Eds. Cognitive Task Analysis.
New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000. 135-146.
|
| |
|
5. |
Decompose, Network, and Asses (DNA)
Method
Shute, V., Sugrue, B., & Willis, R. E. "Automating
Cognitive Task Analysis." In Cognitive Technologies
for Knowledge Assessment Symposium Proceedings, AERA,
Chicago, IL: 1997. An overview of the DNA method. [View
or Download: Local
Copy]
Shute, V. J. & Torreano, L. A. "Formative
Evaluation of an Automated Knowledge Elicitation and
Organization Tool." In Authoring Tools for Advanced
Technology Learning Environments: Toward Cost-Effective
Adaptive, Interactive, and Intelligent Educational Software.
T. Murray, S. Blessing, & S. Ainsworth, Eds. Kluwer: 2002.
A detailed description of the DNA method. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Shute, V. J., Torreano, L. A., & Willis, R. E. DNA:
Providing the Blueprint for Instruction. In Chipman, Shalin
& Schraagen, Eds. Cognitive Task Analysis. New
Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000. 71-86.
|
| |
|
6. |
Task-Knowledge
Structures (TKS)
The
TKS Home Page.
Hamilton, F. "Predictive Evaluation Using Task
Knowledge Structures." In Proceedings of CHI '96
(1996). TKS models are used to predict difficulties users will
have in using new systems. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Hourizi, R. & Johnson, P. "Unmasking Mode
Errors: A New Application of Task Knowledge Principles to the
Knowledge Gaps in Cockpit Design." Proceedings of
Interact '01, The Eighth IFIP Confernece on Human Computer
Interaction, Tokyo (2001). TKS is used to re-design an
automated system in the commercial aviation domain. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Johnson, H. & Johnson, P. "Task Knowledge Structures:
Psychological Basis and Integration into System Design." Acta
Psychologica Vol 78 (1991): 3-26. Outlines the psychological basis
for TKS and describes how task models can be used throughout the system
design process. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Johnson, P., Johnson, H., and Hamilton, F. Getting the
Knowledge into HCI: Theoretical and Practical Aspects of Task
Knowledge Structures. In Chipman, Shalin & Schraagen,
Eds.
Cognitive Task Analysis. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum,
2000. 201-214.
Keep, J. & Johnson, H. "HCI and Requirements
Engineering - Generating Requirements in a Courier Despatch
Management System." SIGCHI Vol 29.1 (1997).
Participatory design and TKS are used to generate requirements
for a courier despatch management system. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Wild, P. J., Johnson, P., & Johnson, H. "An
Hour in the Life: Towards Requirements for Modeling Multiple
Task Work." To appear in Proceeding of CHI ‘2003.
TKS is used to understand multi-tasking. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
7. |
Goal-Directed Task
Analysis (GDTA)
SA Technologies Home
Page. A company founded by Mica Endsley specializing in
Situation Awareness (SA) oriented design.
Endsley, M. From CTA to System Design: Designing to Support
SA. Online Seminar at www.ctaresource.com , delivered September
2002. This online presentation describes GDTA, as well as SA analysis
and measurement. [View or Download: From
Source]
Bolstad, C. A. & Endsley, M. R. Information
Dissonance, Shared Mental Models, and Shared Displays: An
Empirical Evaluation of Information Dominance Techniques.
U.S. Air Force Research Laboratory, Human Effectiveness
Directorate, Report No AFRL-HE-WP-TR-1999-0213 (1998). Issues
regarding team SA (situation awareness), team decision making,
and shared mental models are explored in a microworld
simulation of a team air defense task.
[View or Download: Local
Copy]
Endsley, M. R., Bolte, B., & Jones, D. G. Designing
for situation awareness: An approach to human-centered design.
London: Taylor & Francis (in press). The new text book on
GDTA. Look for it in June 2003.
Endsley, M.R. & Garland, D.J., Eds. Situation
Awareness Analysis and Measurement. Mahwah, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2000. A collection of essays on
the analysis and measurement of SA.
Endsley, M. R. "Situation Awareness and Human
Error: Designing to Support Human Performance."
Proceedings of the High Consequence Systems Surety Conference.
Albuquerque, NM: 1999. The role of SA in human error is
explored. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Endsley, M. R., Farley, T. C., Jones, W. M., & Midkiff,
A. H. Situation Awareness Information Requirements for
Commercial Airline Pilots. International Center for
Air Transporation, Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Cambridge, MA: 1998.
GDTA is used to analyze the job of the commercial airline
pilot. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Endsley, M. R. & Jones, W. M. Situation Awareness
Information Dominance & Information Warfare.
Endsley Consulting. Belmont, MA: 1997. Team SA is studied with
the goal of developing support systems to support information
dominance on the battlefield. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Endsley, M. R. & Robertson, M. M. "Training for
Situation Awareness." In Situation Awareness Analysis
and Measurement. Training for SA is explored in the
commercial aviation domain. [View
or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Endsley, M. R. & Rodgers, M. D. Situation Awareness
Information Requirements for En Route Air Traffic Control. U.S.
Department of Transporation, Federal Aviation Adminstration: 1994. GDTA
is used in the air traffic control domain.
[View or Download: Local
Copy]
Endsley, M. & Hoffman, R. R. "The Sacagawea
Principle." IEEE Intelligient Systems Vol
17.6 (2002). An overview of GDTA.
Farley, T. C., Hansman, R. J., Endsley, M. R., & Amonlirdviman,
K. "The Effects of Shared Information on
Pilot-Controller Situation Awareness and Re-Route
Negotiation." In Proceedings of the 10th International
Symposium on Aviation Psychology. Columbus, Ohio: 1999.
GDTA is applied to the air traffic control domain.
Hanson, M. L., Harper, K. A., Endsley, M., & Rezsonya,
L. "Developing Cognitively Congruent HBR Models via
SAMPLE: A Case Study in Airline Operations Modeling."
In Proceedings
of the 2002 Command and Control Research and Technology
Program (2002). GDTA is used to provide input to a SAMPLE
cognitive model in the airline operations domain.
|
| |
|
8. |
Cognitive Function Model (CFM)
Chrenk, J., Hutton, R. J.B., Klinger, D. W., & Anastasi,
D. "The
Cognimeter: Focusing Cognitive Task Analysis in
the Cognitive Function Model." In Proceedings of the
Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 45th Annaul Meeting
(2001). A software tool to support CFM is described.
|
| |
|
9. |
Cognitively Oriented Task Analysis (COTA)
DuBois, D. A., Shalin, V. L., & Borman, W. C. A
Cognitively-Oriented Approach to Task Analysis and Test
Development. Office of Naval Research, Contract No.
N00014-93-C-0199 (December 1995). An in depth overview of how
to conduct the COTA method. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
DuBois, D. A. & Shalin, V. L. Describing Job Expertise
Using Cognitively Oriented Task Analysis (COTA). In Chipman,
Shalin & Schraagen, Eds. Cognitive Task Analysis.
New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000. 41-56.
|
| |
|
10. |
Hierarchical Task Analysis (HTA)
Davison, H. Cognitive Task Analysis: Current
Research. Power Point Presentation (46 slides).
Provides an overview of cognitive task analysis techniques,
focusing specifically on ACTA and HTA. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Merkelbach, E. J. H. M. & Schraagen, J. M. C. A
Framework for the Analysis of Cognitive Tasks. TNO Human
Factors Research Institute, Report No TNO-TM 1994 B-13 (1994).
Describes a framework for conducting CTA using a combination
of Hierarchical Task Analysis (HTA), Knowledge Analysis and
Documentation System (KADS), and GOMS.
Shepherd, A. Hierarchical Task Analysis. New York:
Taylor & Francis, 2000. A text book on HTA.
|
| |
|
11. |
Interacting Cognitive Subsystems (ICS)
The ICS Home
Page.
Barnard, P.J. & May, J. "Cognitive Modeling for
User Requirements." In Computers, Communication and
Usablity: Design issues, research, and methods for integrated
services. Ed P.F. Byerley, P.J. Barnard, & J May.
Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1993. 101-145. An overview of the ICS
method is provided.
Barnard, P. J. & May, J. Towards a Theory-Based Form of
Cognitive Task Analysis of Broad Scope and Applicability. In
Chipman, Shalin & Schraagen, Eds. Cognitive Task
Analysis. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000. 147-164.
|
| |
|
12. |
Knowledge Analysis and Documentation
System (KADS)
Hickman, F. R., Killin, J. L., Land, L., & Mulhall, T. Analysis
for Knowledge-Based Systems: A Practical Guide to the Kads
Methodology. Ellis Horwood Ltd., 1990. A text book on the
KADS method.
Merkelbach, E. J. H. M. & Schraagen, J. M. C. A
Framework for the Analysis of Cognitive Tasks. TNO Human
Factors Research Institute, Report No TNO-TM 1994 B-13 (1994).
Describes a framework for conducting CTA using a combination
of Hierarchical Task Analysis (HTA), Knowledge Analysis and
Documentation System (KADS), and GOMS.
Schreiber, G., Weilinga, B., & Breuker, J., eds. Kads:
A Principled Approach to Knowledge-Based System Development.
A collection of papers on using KADS in knowledge-based system
development.
|
| |
|
13. |
Team CTA Techniques
Blickensderfer, E., Cannon-Bowers, J. A., Salas, E., &
Baker, D. P. (2000). Analyzing Knowledge Requirements in Team
Tasks, In Schraagen, Chipman, & Shalin, Eds. Cognitive
Task Analysis. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. 431-447.
Cooke, N. Cognitive Task Analysis for Teams.
Unpublished briefing, delivered January 2003. This was Nancy
Cooke’s briefing at www.ctaresource.com that describes
metrics to assess team situation awareness, team decision
making, and shared mental models. [View or Download: From
Source / Local Copy]
Entin, E. E. & Entin, E. B. Measures for Evaluation
of Team Processes and Performance in Experiments and Exercises.
Aptima Inc. Describes metrics to assess team processes. [View
or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Freeman, J. T. & Sefarty, D. Team Collaboration for
Command and Control: A Critical Thinking Model. In Proceedings
of the 2002 Command and Control Research and Technology
Program. Discusses a framework for measuring, managing,
and understanding team critical thinking. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Klein, G. (2000). Cognitive Task Analysis of Teams. In
Schraagen, Chipman, & Shalin, Eds. Cognitive Task
Analysis. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. 417-430.
MacMillan, J., Paley, M. J., Sefarty, D., & Levchuk, Y.
N. Designing the Best Team for the Task: A Method that
Combines Algorithms, Heuristics, and Expert Judgment.
Aptima, Inc. Describes a systematic approach for designing
teams that uses a quantitative task structure. [View or
Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
MacMillan, J., Sefarty, D., Paley, M. J., & Levchuk, Y.
N. Designing the Information Space for a Command Center
Based on Team Performance Models. Office of Naval Research
Manning and Affordability Initiative. Describes how modeling
of team information needs and communication patters supported
the layout of a command center. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Shope, S. M. & Cooke, N. J. Facility for Cognitive
Engineering Research on Team Tasks (CERTT). New Mexico State
University, CERTT Laboratory (1998). Describes the design of a
lab to support research on team cognition and the develop of
evaluations and measures to support this research. The lab’s
first microworld simulation of a UAV task is described. [View
or Download: Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
|
| |
B. |
Knowledge
Elicitation
Diaper, D., Ed. Knowledge Elicitation: Principles,
Techniques, and Applications. NY: John Wiley & Sons,
1989. A collection of papers on various knowledge elicitation
techniques by the originators of those techniques.
Cooke, N. J. "Varieties of Knowledge Elicitation
Techniques." International Journal of Human-Computer
Studies Vol 41 (1994): 801-849. A comprehensive survey and
classification of knowledge elicitation techniques.
Hoffman, R. R., Shadbolt, N. R., Burton, A. M., & Klein,
G. "Eliciting Knowledge from Experts: A Methodological
Analysis." Organizational Behavioral and Human Decision
Processes Vol 62.2 (1995): 129-158. Describes and
categorizes a variety of knowledge elicitation techniques,
including Think-Aloud, Interviews, Rating and Sorting tasks, and
Task Analysis.
Wilson, M. D., Barnard, P.J., Green, T. R. G., & MacLean,
A. Knowledge-Based Task Analysis for Human-Computer
Systems.
1987. Describes Task Analysis for Knowledge Descriptions (TAKDS),
Command Language Grammar, Task Action Grammar, GOMS, User Device
Model, CTA, and Decomposition of Mental Activity. [View or
Download: Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
Interviewing/Observing
Methods: |
| |
|
1. |
Unstructured Interviews
"Conducting Interviews." Course Notes From
Research Methods for Language Study. Offers tips in conducting unstructured
and structured interviews. [View or Download: From
Source]
Scott, A. A., Clayton, J. E. & Gibson, E. L. (1991). A
Practical Guide to Knowledge Acquisition. Reading, MA:
Addison-Wesley. This book is intended to guide the development
of an expert system, and provides an entire section on
interviewing experts.
Weiss, S. & Kulikowski, C. (1984). A Practical Guide
to Designing Expert Systems. Totowa, NJ: Rowan and
Allenheld. This book discusses many techniques about eliciting
knowledge from experts, and includes a section on
interviewing.
|
| |
|
2. |
Structured Interviews
Roth, E. M., Malsh, N., & Multer, J. Understanding
How Train Dispatchers Manage and Control Trains: Results of a
Cognitive Task Analysis. U.S. Department of Transporation
(2001). Describes how field observations and structured
interviews were used to learn about train dispatching. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
Wood, L. E.. "Semi-Structured Interviewing for
User-Centered Design." interactions Vol 4.2
(1997). Describes structured interviewing techniques similar
to those of Contextual Inquiry. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Wood, L. E & Ford, J.M. "Structuring interviews
with experts during knowledge elicititation." International
Journal of Intelligent Systems: Special Issue on
Knowledge Acquisition Vol 8 (1993): 71-90. Describes
questions for different phases of the interview that build
from concepts to relations and finally to rules.
|
| |
|
3. |
Step Listing
Schvaneveldt, R. W., Durso, F. T., Goldsmith, T. E., Breen,
T. J., Cooke, N. M., Tucker, R. G. & DeMaio, J. C.
"Measuring the structure of expertise." International
Journal of Man-Machine Studies Vol 23 (1985): 699-728.
Step listing is described and used to identify concepts
critical to air-combat flight maneuvers.
|
| |
|
4. |
Group Interview
Boose, J.H. Expertise Transfer for Expert System Design.
Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1986. A variety of group interview
techniques are discussed, including the Delphi technique and
the Crawford Slip Method.
Boy, G. A. "The Group Elicitation Method for
Participatory Design and Usability Testing." Interactions
(March/April 1997). Presents the Group Elicitation Method
(GEM), a brainstorming technique augmented by a decision
support system for conducting participatory design and
usability testing.
Grabowski, M., Massey, A. P., & Wallace, W. A..
"Focus groups as a group knowledge elicitation technique."
Knowledge Acquisition Vol 4 (1992): 407-425. Focus
group interviews are compared to individual interviews. While
both methods produce similar quantities of information, focus
groups are found to elicit more original responses.
Krueger, R. A. "Designing and Conducting Focus Group
Interviews." Unpublished Course Notes, University of
Minnesota: 2002. Useful notes on the methodology of conducting
focus group interviews from the point of view of a social
psychology researcher. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
McGraw, K. & Harbison-Briggs, K. Knowledge
Acquisition: Principles and Guidelines. NJ: Prentice Hall,
1989. Several group interview techniques are discussed,
including brainstorming, consensus decision making, the
nominal group technique, and computer-facilitated sessions.
Peterson, B., Stine, J. L., & Darken, R. P. "A
process and representation for modeling expert
navigators." In Proceedings of the 9th Conference on
Computer Generated Forces and Behavioral Representations
(2000): 459-470. Describes the knowledge elicitation and
knowledge representation of a study of expert navigators.
Focus groups were used to elicit knowledge, and an executable
cognitive model was used to represent knowledge. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
5. |
Questionnaires
Schweigert, W. A. Research Methods and Statistics for
Psychology. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole Publishing Co.,
1994. An introductory text on conducting psychology research.
Includes chapters on basic statistics, experiment design, and
questionnaires.
Sinclair, M. A. "Subjective assessment." In Evaluation
of Human Work: A Practical Ergonomics Methodology. Ed. J.
R. Wilson & E. N. Corlett. London: Taylor & Francis,
1990. Provides a good summary of questionnaire design and
analysis.
|
| |
|
6. |
Teachback
Johnson L. & Johnson N. "Knowledge elicitation
involving teachback interviewing." In Knowledge
Elicitation for Expert Systems: A Practical Handbook Ed.
A. Kidd. New York: Plenum Press, 1987. 91-108. Describes the
teachback technique.
|
| |
|
7. |
Field Observations/Ethnographic Methods
Bentley, R., Hughes, J. A., Randall, D., Rodden, T.,
Sawyer, P., Shapiro, D., & Sommerville, I.
"Ethnographically-informed systems design for air traffic
control." In Proceedings of the ACM Conference on
Computer Supported Cooperative Work (1992). An
ethnographic study of air traffic controllers is used to
inform the design of the user interface to a flight database.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Hughes, J., O'Brien, J., Rodden, T., Rouncefield, M., &
Sommerville, I. "Presenting ethnography in the
requirements process." Software Engineering Research
Group, University of Lancaster, Report No. SE/5/199 (1994).
Examines systematic approaches to involve ethnography in the
requirements process in the design of interactive
systems."
Hughes, J., King, V., Rodden, T., & Andersen, H.
"Moving out from the control room: ethnography in system
design." Center for
Research in CSCW (Computer Supported Cooperative Work),
Lancaster University, Report No. CSCW/9/1994 (1994). Examines
the use of ethnography in a number of different system design
projects in a variety of domains. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Millen, D. R. "Rapid Ethnography: Time Deepening
Strategies for HCI Field Research." In Proceeding on
Designing Interactive Systems: Processes, Practices, Methods,
and Techniques (August 2000). Rapid ethnography methods
are applied to HCI design. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Patterson, E. S., Woods, D. D., Sarter, N. B., & Watts-Perotti,
J. Patterns in Cooperative Cognition. Field
observations and computer simulations are used to study
medical command and control, air traffic control, and space
shuttle mission control. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Roth, E. M & Patterson, E. S. (2000). Using
Observational Study as a Tool for Discovery: Uncovering
Cognitive and Collaborative Demands and Adaptive Strategies.
Presented at the 5th Conference on Naturalistic
Decision Making, in press. Studies of train dispatching and
the use of advanced human-system interfaces in a nuclear
powerplant illustrate the methods used in conducting and
analyzing the results of observational studies. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
Roth, E. M. Using Observational Study as a Tool for
Discovery: Uncovering Cognitive and Collaborative Demands and
Adaptive Strategies. Unpublished briefing, delivered
February 2003. This was Emilie Roth’s briefing at
www.ctaresource.com describing her experience conducting
observational research. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Roth, E. & O'Hara, J. "Integrating Digital and
Conventional Human-System Interfaces: Lessons Learned from a
Control Room Modernization Program." U.S. Nuclear
Regulatory Commission, September 2002. Field observations,
interviews, and computer simulation are used to study a
recently modernized nuclear control room. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
Roth, E. M., Malsh, N., & Multer, J. Understanding
How Train Dispatchers Manage and Control Trains: Results of a
Cognitive Task Analysis. U.S. Department of Transporation
(2001). Describes how field observations and structured
interviews were used to learn about train dispatching. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
Shuler, D. & Namioka, A., Eds. Participatory Design:
Principles and Practices. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum,
1993. A collection of papers about design techniques that
focus on users, including ethnographic methods.
Woods, D. D. Process-Tracing Methods for the Study of
Cognition Outside of the Experimental Psychology Laboratory.
In Klein, G. A., Orasanu, J., Calderwood, R., & Zsambok,
C. E., Eds. Decision Making in Action: Models and Methods.
NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. Process tracing techniques
applied to Think-Aloud, Critical Incident Analysis, Field
Observations, and Field Experimentation.
|
| |
|
8. |
Twenty Questions
B, J. & W, B. "Use of models in the interpretation
of verbal data." In A. Kidd, Ed. Knowledge Acquisition
for Expert Systems. New York: Plenum Press,1987: 17-43.
Grover, M. D. "A pragmatic knowledge acquisition
methodology." In Proceedings of the 8th
International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence
(1983): 436-438.
Shadbolt, N. & Burton, M. "Knowledge
elicitation." In J. R. Wilson & E. N. Corlett, Eds.
Evaluation of Human Work: A Practical Ergonomics Methodology.
London: Taylor & Francis, 1990: 321-345.
Welbank, M. "An overview of knowledge acquisition
methods." Interacting with Computers Vol 2 (1990):
83-91.
|
| |
|
Process Tracing
Methods
Woods, D. D. Process-Tracing Methods for the Study of
Cognition Outside of the Experimental Psychology Laboratory.
In Klein, G. A., Orasanu, J., Calderwood, R., & Zsambok,
C. E., Eds. Decision Making in Action: Models and Methods.
NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. Process tracing techniques
applied to Think-Aloud, Critical Incident Analysis, Field
Observations, and Field Experimentation.
|
| |
|
9. |
Discourse/Conversation/Interaction
Analysis
Belkin, N. J., Brooks, H. M., & Daniels, P. J.
"Knowledge elicitation using discourse analysis." International
Journal of Man-Machine Studies Vol 27 (1987): 127-144.
Olson, J. R. & Biolsi, K. J. "Techniques for
representing expert knowledge." In K.A. Ericsson & J.
Smith, Eds. Toward a General Theory of Expertise.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991. 240-285.
|
| |
|
10. |
Activity Sampling
Tijerinia, L., Kiger, S., Wierwille, W., Rockwell, T.,
Kantowitz, B., Bittner, A., Nygren, T.; Myers, C., Tolbert,
C., & McCallum, M. Heavy Vehicle Driver Workload
Assessment, Task 1: Task Analysis Data and Protocols Review.
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (1992).
Activity sampling, interviews, and the critical incident
technique are used to assess heavy vehicle driver workload.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
11. |
Think-Aloud Problem-Solving/Protocol Analysis
Conrad, F., Blair, J., & Tracy, E. "Verbal Reports
are Data! A Theoretical Approach to Cognitive
Interviews." Presents an approach to collecting an
analyzing cognitive interview data. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Ericsson, K. A. & Simon, H. A. Protocol Analysis:
Revised Edition. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1993. A
text book on think-aloud problem solving and protocol
analysis. [View or Download: From
Source]
Gordan, T. R., Coovert, M. D., Riddle, D. L, & Miles, D. E. "Classifying C2 Decision Making
Jobs Using Cognitive Task Analysis and Verbal Protocol
Analysis." In Proceedings of the 6th International
Command and Control Research Technology Symposium (2001).
CTA and verbal protocol analysis are used to analyze AWACS
Weapons Director teams. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Lees, C., Manton, J., & Triggs, T. Protocol Analysis
as a Tool in Function and Task Analysis. DSTO Electronics
and Surveillance Research Laboratory. Salisbury, South
Australia (1999). The kinds of information that protocol
analysis can provide that might be useful in function/task
analysis are examined. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Woods, D. D. Process-Tracing Methods for the Study of
Cognition Outside of the Experimental Psychology Laboratory.
In Klein, G. A., Orasanu, J., Calderwood, R., & Zsambok,
C. E., Eds. Decision Making in Action: Models and Methods.
NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. Process tracing techniques
applied to Think-Aloud, Critical Incident Analysis, Field
Observations, and Field Experimentation.
|
| |
|
12. |
Retrospective/Aided Recall
Wood, L. E. & Ford, J.M. "Structuring interviews
with experts during knowledge elcititation." International
Journal of Intelligent Systems: Special Issue on
Knowledge Acquisition Vol 8 (1993): 71-90. Briefly
describes the retrospective/aided recall technique.
Zachary, W. W., Ryder, J. M., & Hicinbothom, J. H.
Building Cognitive Task Analyses and Models of a
Decision-Making Team in a Complex Real-Time Environment. In
Chipman, Shalin & Schraagen, Eds. Cognitive Task
Analysis. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000. 365-384.
Describes how the COGNET framework can be used to conduct CTA.
The use of retrospective/aided recall to elicit knowledge is
discussed. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
13. |
Interruption Analysis
Olson, J. R. & Reuter, H. H. "Extracting expertise
from experts: methods for knowledge acquisition." Expert
Systems Vol 4 (1987): 152-168.
|
| |
|
14. |
Shadowing Another
Clarke, B. "Knowledge Acquisition for real-time
knowledge-based systems." In Proceedings of the First
European Workshop on Knowledge Acquisition for Knowledge Based
Systems, UK (September 1987).
|
| |
|
15. |
Shadowing Self
Ericsson, K. A. & Simon H. A. Protocol Analysis:
Verbal Reports as Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1984. A
textbook on protocol analysis.
Cordingley, E. S. "Knowledge elicitation techniques
for knowledge-based systems." In D. Diaper, Ed. Knowledge
Elicitation: Principles, Techniques, and Applications. New
York: John Wiley & Sons, 1989. 89-175.
|
| |
|
16. |
Simulators/Mockups and Microworld
Simulation
Cooke, N. J., Shope, S. M., & Kiekel, P. A. Shared-Knowledge
and Team Performance: A Cognitive Engineering Approach to
Measurement. Air Force Research Laboratory (March 2001).
Team decision making processes and team situation awareness
issues are explored in a microworld simulation of a team UAV
operations task. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Entin, E., Sefarty, D., Elliot, L., & Schiflett, S. G. DMT-Rnet:
An Internet-based Infrastructure for Distributed
Multidisciplinary Investigations of C2 Performance. Aptima,
Inc. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Fahey, R. P., Rowe, A. L., Dunlap, K. L., & deBoom, D.
O. Synthetic Task Design: Cognitive Task Analysis of AWACS
Weapons Director Teams. U.S. Air Force Research Laboratory
(July 2001). The critical incident method and other
interviewing techniques are used to perform a CTA of AWACS
weapons directors. The results are used to inform the design
of a microworld simulation of AWACS weapon director team tasks.
[View or Download: Local
Copy]
Gray, W. D. "Simulated Task Environments: The Role of
High-Fidelity Simulations, Scaled Worlds, Synthetic
Environments, and Laboratory Tasks in Basic and Applied
Cognitive Research." Cogntive Science Quarterly
Vol 2 (2002): 205-227. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Hess, S. M., MacMillan, J., Sefarty, D., & Elliot, L. From
Cognitive Task Analysis to Simulation: Developing a Synthetic
Team Task for AWACS Weapons Directors. Air Force Research
Laboratory. A CTA of AWACS weapons directors is performed and
used to inform the design of a microworld simulation of a team
task for weapons directors. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Stammers, R. B. "Psychological Aspects of Simulator
Design and Use." Advances in Nuclear Science and
Technology Vol 17 (1986): 117-132.
|
| |
|
17. |
Exploratory Sequential Data Analysis (ESDA)
MacShapa Software Home
Page. MacShapa is a software tool to perform
exploratory sequential data analysis..
Fisher, C. & Sanderson, P. "Exploratory Sequential
Data Analysis: Exploring Continuous Observational Data." Interactions
(March 1996).
Sanderson, P. M., & Fisher, C. "Exploratory
Sequential Data Analysis: Foundations." Human-Computer
Interaction Vol 9 (1994): 251-317.
Sanderson, P. M., Scott, J. J., Johnston, T., Mainzer, J.,
Watanabe, L. M. , & James, J. M. "MacSHAPA and the
enterprise of exploratory sequential data analysis (ESDA)."
International Journal of Human-Computer Studies Vol 41
(1994): 633-681.
|
| |
|
18. |
Minimal Scenario Technique
Geiwitz et al. Knowledge Acquisition for Expert Systems:
Conceptual and Empirical Comparisons. Santa Barbara, CA:
Anacapa Sciences, 1988.
|
| |
|
19. |
Critical Incident Technique (CIT)
Flanagan, J. C. "The critical incident
technique." Psychological Bulletin Vol 51.4
(1954): 327-358. The seminal paper on the CIT.
Black, J. B., Dimarki, E., van Esselstyn, D., &
Flanagan, R. "Using a Knowledge Representation Approach
to Cognitive Task Analysis." In Proceedings of the
1995 Annual National Convention of the Association for
Educational Communications and Technology (AECT). Anaheim,
CA: 1995. Field observations and critical incident probes are
used in a CTA of the medical domain. [View or Download:
Local
Copy]
Cohen, M. S. et. al. Rapid Capturing of Battlefield
Mental Models. United States Army Research Institute, Fort
Leavenworth Field Unit, Kansas (1995). Critical incident
interviews and think-aloud analyses are used to capture
battlefield mental models. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Woods, D. D. Process-Tracing Methods for the Study of
Cognition Outside of the Experimental Psychology Laboratory.
In Klein, G. A., Orasanu, J., Calderwood, R., & Zsambok,
C. E., Eds. Decision Making in Action: Models and Methods.
NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. Process tracing techniques
applied to Think-Aloud, Critical Incident Analysis, Field
Observations, and Field Experimentation.
|
| |
|
20. |
Cloze Technique
Leddo, J. & Cohen, M. S. Objective Structure
Analysis: A method of Eliciting Expert Knowledge.
Alexandria, VA: Army Research Institute, 1988.
|
| |
|
21. |
Critiquing
Miller, J. E., Patterson, Emily S., & Woods, David D.
"Critiquing as a Cognitive Task Analysis
(CTA)
Methodology." In Proceedings of the Human Factors and
Ergonomics Society 45th Annual Meeting. Minneapolis, MN:
2001. 518-522. The critiquing method is described and used to
analyze expert assessment of the Ariane 501 rocket launch
failure. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
22. |
Crystal Ball/Stumbling Block Technique
Cohen, M. S., Freeman, J. T. & Thompson, B. T.
"Critical Thinking Skills in Tactical Decision Making: A
Model and A Training Method." In Canon-Bowers, J. &
E. Salas , Eds. Decision-Making Under Stress: Implications
for Training & Simulation. Washington, DC: American
Psychological Association Publications, 1998.
|
| |
|
23. |
Table-Top Analysis
Gustafson, D., Shulka, R., Delbecq, A. & Walister, G.
(1975). "A comparative Study of the Differences in
Subjective Likelihood Estimates Made by Individuals,
Interacting Groups, Delphi Groups, and Nominal Groups." Organizational
Behavior and Human Performance Vol 9 (1975): 280-291.
|
| |
|
24. |
Wizard of Oz Technique
Cordingley, E. S. "Knowledge elicitation techniques
for knowledge-based systems." In D. Diaper, Ed. Knowledge
Elicitation: Principles, Techniques, and Applications. New
York: John Wiley & Sons, 1989. 89-175.
Maulsby, D., Greenberg, S., & Mander, R.
"Prototyping an Intelligent Agent through Wizard of
Oz." In Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human
Factors in Computing Systems ( May 1993). The Wizard of Oz
technique is used to test the design of a teachable agent.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
Conceptual
Methods |
| |
|
25. |
Decision Analysis
Bradshaw, J. M. & Boose, J. H. "Decision analysis
techniques for knowledge acquisition: combining information
and preferences using Acquinas and Axotl." International
Journal of Man-Machine Studies Vol 32 (1990): 121-186. A
review of decision analysis techniques and how they have been
incorporated in the design of two expert systems.
Fischhoff, B. "Eliciting Knowledge for Analytical
Representation." IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man,
and Cybernetics Vol 19.3 (1989): 448-461. A review of
decision analysis techniques.
Keeney, R. L. Decision Analysis: State of the
Field.
Woodward Clyde Consultants, Tech Report No. 82-2. San
Francisco, CA (March 1982). Written for the non-decision
analyst, describes what decision analysis is and what it can
and cannot do. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Goldstein, W. M. & Hogarth, R. M., Eds. Research on
Judgment and Decision Making: Currents, Connections, and
Controversies. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press,
1997. A collection of papers by current researchers in the
field of judgment and decision making.
Hart, A. Knowledge Acquisition for Expert Systems.
London: Kogan Page, 1986.
Wright, G. & Bolger, F., Eds. Expertise and Decision
Support. New York: Plenum Press, 1992.
|
| |
|
26. |
Rating and Sorting Tasks
Cordingley, E. S. "Knowledge elicitation techniques
for knowledge-based systems." In D. Diaper, Ed. Knowledge
Elicitation: Principles, Techniques, and Applications. New
York: John Wiley & Sons, 1989. 89-175.
Geiwitz, J., Kornell, J., & McCloskey, B. P. "An
Expert System for the Selection of Knowledge Acquisition
Techniques." Technical Report 785-2. Santa Barbara, CA:
Anacapa Sciences, 1990.
Zachary, W. W., Ryder, J. M., & Purcell, J. A. "A
computer based tool to support mental modeling for
human-computer interface design." CHI Systems Tech Report
No 900831-8908 (August 1990). Describes magnitude estimation,
reference ranking, repertory grid, q sort, and other rating
and sorting techniques, as well as a software tool to support
these techniques.
|
| |
|
27. |
Magnitude Estimation
Zachary, W. W., Ryder, J. M., & Purcell, J. A. "A
computer based tool to support mental modeling for
human-computer interface design." CHI Systems Tech Report
No 900831-8908 (August 1990). Describes a software tool to
support magnitude estimation.
|
| |
|
28. |
Repertory Grid Technique
The Repertory Grid Knowledge Elicitation Software Tool Home
Page. A software tool to aid in repertory grid
analysis.
Bhatia, S. K. & Yao, Q. "A New Approach to
Knowledge Acquisition by Repertory Grids." In Proceedings
of the 2nd International Conference on Information and
Knowledge Management (December 1993). Describes a
variation of the repertory grid technique. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
Boose, J. H. Uses of repertory grid-centered knowledge
acquisition tools for knowledge-bases systems. In J. H. Boose
& B. R. Gaines, Eds. The Foundations of Knowledge
Acquisition . San Diego, CA: Academic Press, 1990. 61-84.
Bradshaw, J. M., Ford, K. M., Adams-Webber, J. R., &
Boose, J. H. "Beyond the repertory grid: new approaches
to constructivist knowledge acquisition tools
development." International Journal of Intelligent
Systems Vol 8 (1993): 287-333.
Cordingley, E. S. "Knowledge elicitation techniques
for knowledge-based systems." In D. Diaper, Ed. Knowledge
Elicitation: Principles, Techniques, and Applications. New
York: John Wiley & Sons, 1989. 89-175.
Gaines, B. R. & Shaw M. L. G. "Knowledge
acquisition tools based on personal construct theory." Knowledge
Engineering Review: Special Issue on Automated Knowledge
Acquisition Tools (1992). Describes the repertory grid
technique in detail.
Zacharias, G., Illgen, C., Asdigha, M., Yara, J., &
Hudlicka, E. "VIEW: Visualization and Interactive
Elicitation Workstation--A Tool for Representing the
Commander's Mental Model of the Battlefield." ARI
Research Note 97-01 (December 1996). Describes the development
of a software tool to assist in eliciting and representing
commander’s mental models. Techniques used include repertory
grid analysis, multidimensional scaling, and cluster
analysis. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
Zachary, W. W., Ryder, J. M., & Purcell, J. A. "A
computer based tool to support mental modeling for
human-computer interface design." CHI Systems Tech Report
No 900831-8908 (August 1990). Describes a software tool to
support the repertory grid technique.
|
| |
|
29. |
P Sort
Zachary, W. W., Ryder, J. M., & Purcell, J. A. "A
computer based tool to support mental modeling for
human-computer interface design." CHI Systems Tech Report
No 900831-8908 (August 1990). Describes several sorting
procedures, including P Sort.
|
| |
|
30. |
Q Sort
Zachary, W. W., Ryder, J. M., & Purcell, J. A. "A
computer based tool to support mental modeling for
human-computer interface design." CHI Systems Tech Report
No 900831-8908 (August 1990). Describes several sorting
procedures, including P Sort.
|
| |
|
31. |
Hierarchical Sort
Shadbolt, N. & Burton, M. Knowledge elicitation.
In J. R. Wilson & E. N. Corlett, Eds. Evaluation of Human
Work: A Practical Ergonomics Methodology. London: Taylor &
Francis, 1990: 321-345.
|
| |
|
32. |
Cluster Analysis
Corter, J. E. & Tversky, A. Extended similarity
trees. Psychometrika,
Vol 51 (1986): 429-451.
Leddo, J. M., Mullin, T. M., Cohen, M. S., Bresnick, T. A.,
Marvin, F. F., & O'Connor, M. F. Knowledge elicitation:
Phase I final report (Volume 1, Technical Report 87-15).
Alexandria, VA: Army Research Institute, 1988. Presents a
framework for knowledge elicitation and representation based
on theories of how experts represent knowledge.
Lewis, S. "Cluster Analysis as a technique to guide
interface design." International Journal of
Man-Machine Studies Vol 35 (1991): 251-265. Describes how
hierarchical clustering techniques, which reduce a set of data
to a hierarchical set of clusters, may be used to guide
interface design.
Zacharias, G., Illgen, C., Asdigha, M., Yara, J., &
Hudlicka, E. "VIEW: Visualization and Interactive
Elicitation Workstation--A Tool for Representing the
Commander's Mental Model of the Battlefield." ARI
Research Note 97-01 (December 1996). Describes the development
of a software tool to assist in eliciting and representing
commander’s mental models. Techniques used include repertory
grid analysis, multidimensional scaling, and cluster
analysis. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
33. |
Multidimensional Scaling (MDS)
Cooke, N. J. "Predicting judgment time from measures
of psychological proximity." Journal of Experimental
Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition Vol 18 (1992):
640-653.
Cooke, N. M. Durso, F. T., & Schvaneveldt, R. W.
"Recall and measures of memory organization." Journal
of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition
Vol 12 (1986): 538-549.
Schenkman, B. N. "Perceived
Similarities and
Preferences for Consumer Electronic Products." Personal
and Ubiquitous Computing Vol 6.2 (2002). A sample of 36
people judged the similarity of 20 electronic appliances;
multidimensional scaling was used to analyze the results.
Zacharias, G., Illgen, C., Asdigha, M., Yara, J., &
Hudlicka, E. "VIEW: Visualization and Interactive
Elicitation Workstation--A Tool for Representing the
Commander's Mental Model of the Battlefield." ARI
Research Note 97-01 (December 1996). Describes the development
of a software tool to assist in eliciting and representing
commander’s mental models. Techniques used include repertory
grid analysis, multidimensional scaling, and cluster
analysis. [View or Download: Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
34. |
Likert Scale Elicitation
Geiwitz, J., & Schwartz, D.R. Delco Soldier-Machine
Interface: Demonstration and evaluation (Technical Report
714-3). Santa Barbara, CA: Anacapa Sciences, 1987.
Geiwitz, J., Klatsky, R. L. & McCloskey, B. P. Knowledge
Acquisition for Expert Systems: Conceptual and Empirical
Comparisons. Santa Barbara, CA: Anacapa Sciences, 1988.
|
| |
|
35. |
Structural Analysis Techniques
Boose, J. H. Uses of repertory grid-centered knowledge
acquisition tools for knowledge-bases systems. In J. H. Boose
& B. R. Gaines, Eds. The Foundations of Knowledge
Acquisition . San Diego, CA: Academic Press, 1990. 61-84.
Cooke, N. M & McDonald, J. E. "The application of
psychological scaling techniques to knowledge elicitation for
knowledge-based systems." International Journal of
Man-Machine Studies Vol 26 (1987): 533-550.
Schvaneveldt, R. W., Durso, F. T., Goldsmith, T. E., Breen,
T. J., & Cooke, N.M. "Measuring the structure of
expertise." International Journal of Man-Machine
Studies Vol 23 1985: 699-728.
|
| |
|
36. |
Conceptual Graph Construction
IHMC Concept Map Software Home
Page. A software tool for creating and sharing
knowledge models represented as concept maps. Also has links to
publications, tutorials, and example concept maps.
Carnot, M. J., Dunn, B., & Canas, A. J. Concept Maps
vs. Web Pages for Information Searching and Browsing.
Institute for Human and Machine Cognition. Internet browsers based on a concept map-based interface were
compared to standard page-based browsers for ease in finding
information. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Coffey, J. W., Hoffman, R. R., Canas, A. J., & Ford, K.
M. A Concept Map-Based Knowledge Modeling Approach to
Expert Knowledge Sharing. Institute for Human and Machine
Cognition. The PreSERVe
method of knowledge elicitation and a knowledge representation
scheme based on concept maps is described in the context of a
case study of weather forecasting. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
Gordon, S.E., Schmierer, K. A., & Gill, R. T.
Conceptual graph analysis: Knowledge acquisition for
instructional system design. Human Factors Vol 35.3
(1993): 459-481.
Gordon, S. E. & Gill, R. T. Cognitive Task Analysis. In
C.E. Zsambok & G. Klein, Eds. Naturalistic Decision
Making. Mahway, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1997. 131-140.
Provides an overview of CTA techniques, with brief description
of Concept Mapping, COGNET, Conceptual Graph Analysis, and
PARI.
Reichert, M. & Dadam, P. A Framework for Dynamic
Changes in Workflow Management Systems. Dexa Workshop
(1997). An approach to modeling workflow using conceptual
graphs is described. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Thorsden, M. "A comparison of two tools for cognitive
task analysis: Concept mapping and the critical decision
method." In Proceedings of the Human Factors and
Ergonomics Society 35th Annual Meeting (1991).
Concept mapping and the critical decision method are compared.
|
| |
|
37. |
Diagramming
Geiwitz, J., Klatsky, R. L. & McCloskey, B. P. Knowledge
Acquisition for Expert Systems: Conceptual and Empirical
Comparisons. Santa Barbara, CA: Anacapa Sciences, 1988.
|
| |
|
38. |
Laddering
Diederich, J., Ruhmann, I., & May, M. "KRITON: a
knowledge acquisition tool for expert systems." International
Journal of Man-Machine Studies Vol 26 (1987): 29-40.
Shadbolt, N. & Burton, M. "Knowledge
elicitation."
In J. R. Wilson & E. N. Corlett, Eds. Evaluation of Human
Work: A Practical Ergonomics Methodology. London: Taylor &
Francis, 1990: 321-345.
|
| |
|
39. |
Influence Diagram Construction
Howard, R. A. & Matheson, J. E. Influence diagrams.
In readings on the principles of applications of decision
analysis (Vol. 2). Palo Alto, CA: Professional Collection,
Strategic Decision Group, 1984.
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
C. |
Computational
Cognitive Modeling
Byrne, M. D. Cognitive Architecture. An introduction
to modeling cognition with Integrated Cognitive Architectures.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Campbell, G. E. & Cannon-Bowers, J. A. The
Application of Human Performance Models in the Design and
Operation of Complex Systems. Office of Naval Research,
SC-21 Science and Technology Manning Affordability Initiative.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Gray, W. D. & Altmann, E. M. Cognitive Modeling and
Human-Computer Interaction. In W. Karwowski, Ed.
International encyclopedia of ergonomics and human factors
(Vol. 1). New York: Taylor & Francis, Ltd. 387-391.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Pew, R. W. & Mavor, A. S., Eds. Modeling Human and
Organizational Behavior: Applications to Military Simulations.
Washington, D. C.: National Academy Press, 1998.
Polk, T. A. & Seifert, C. M. Cognitive Modeling.
Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2002.
Ritter, F. E., Baxter, G. D., Jones, G., & Young, R. M.
"Supporting Cognitive Models as Users."
ACM
Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction Vol. 7.2
(2000). [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
GOMS Family of Models
GOMS Model
Work Home Page. GOMS resources at the University of
Michigan. Their goal is to transition GOMS modeling research
results to industry.
Card, S. K., Moran, T. P., & Newell, A. The
Psychology of Human-Computer Interaction. A seminal work
in the field of HCI. Introduced the GOMS approach. Mahwah, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1983.
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. The GOMS Family of Analysis
Techniques: Tools for Design and Evaluation. Human-Computer
Interaction Institute Technical Report CMU-HCII-94-106 (1994).
An overview of the GOMS family of models, including KLM, GOMS,
CMN-GOMS, NGOMSL, and CPM-GOMS. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. "Using GOMS for User
Interface Design and Evaluation: Which Technique?"
ACM
Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction Vol. 3.4
(1996): 287-319. Provides guidance about which GOMS variant to
use to meet different design goals. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Nielsen, J. & Phillips, V. L. "Estimating the
Relative Usability of Two Interfaces: Heuristic, Formal, and
Empirical Methods Compared." In Proceedings of CHI '93
(April 1993). Heurisitc evaluation, GOMS, and usability
testing are compared in an examination of two user interfaces.
|
| |
|
1. |
Keystroke Level Model (KLM)
Haunold, P. & Kuhn, W. "A Keystroke Level Analysis
of Manual Map Digitizing." In Proceedings of CHI 1994.
Boston, MA: 1994. 337-343. Examines the suitability of the
Keystroke Level Model for analyzing manual map digitizing
tasks. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. The GOMS Family of Analysis
Techniques: Tools for Design and Evaluation. Human-Computer
Interaction Institute Technical Report CMU-HCII-94-106 (1994).
An overview of the GOMS family of models, including KLM, GOMS,
CMN-GOMS, NGOMSL, and CPM-GOMS. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. "Using GOMS for User
Interface Design and Evaluation: Which Technique?"
ACM
Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction Vol. 3.4
(1996): 287-319. Provides guidance about which GOMS variant to
use to meet different design goals. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
2. |
CMN-GOMS (Card Moran Newell GOMS)
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. The GOMS Family of Analysis
Techniques: Tools for Design and Evaluation. Human-Computer
Interaction Institute Technical Report CMU-HCII-94-106 (1994).
An overview of the GOMS family of models, including KLM, GOMS,
CMN-GOMS, NGOMSL, and CPM-GOMS. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. "Using GOMS for User
Interface Design and Evaluation: Which Technique?"
ACM
Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction Vol. 3.4
(1996): 287-319. Provides guidance about which GOMS variant to
use to meet different design goals. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
3. |
NGOMSL (Natural GOMS Language)
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. The GOMS Family of Analysis
Techniques: Tools for Design and Evaluation. Human-Computer
Interaction Institute Technical Report CMU-HCII-94-106 (1994).
An overview of the GOMS family of models, including KLM, GOMS,
CMN-GOMS, NGOMSL, and CPM-GOMS. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Kieras, D. E. A Guide to GOMS Model Usability Evaluation
using NGOMSL. In The Handbook of Human-Computer Interaction
(2nd Edition). North Holland: 1996. Presents the parts of a
GOMS model in terms of NGOMSL notation, presents a procedure
for constructing GOMS models, and explains how to use a GOMS
model evaluation of a design for predicting human performance.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Kieras, D. E. "GOMS Modeling of User Interfaces using
NGOMSL." In Proceeding of CHI 1994. Presents the
NGOMSL methodology for constructing and using GOMS models for
use in analytical user interface design evaluation.
Kieras, D. A Guide to GOMS Model Usability Evaluation
using GOMSL and GLEAN3. University of Michigan (1999).
Presents an executable form of NGOMSL called GOMSL which is
processed and executed by a GOMS model simulation tool called
GLEAN3. GLEAN3 is based on a simplified version of EPIC.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Kieras, D. E., Wood, S. D., Abotel, K., & Hornof, A.
GLEAN: A Computer-Based Tool for Rapid GOMS Model Usability
Evaluation of User Interface Designs. In ACM Symposium on User
Interface Software and Technology (1995). A computer-based
tool, GLEAN, that generates quantitative predictions regarding
human performance from a supplied GOMS model is described.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
Santoro, T.P., Kieras, D.E., & Campbell, G.E. GOMS
Modeling Application to Watchstation Design Using the GLEAN
Tool. The GLEAN tool is used to support the design of a
watchstation interface. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
4. |
CPM-GOMS (Critical Path
Method/Cognitive-Perceptual-Motor GOMS)
Gray, W. D., John, B. E., & Atwood, M. E. "The
Precis of Project Ernestine Or An Overview of a Validation of
GOMS." In Proceedings of CHI '92 (May 1992).
CPM-GOMS is used to model a telephone operator workstation.
[View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. The GOMS Family of Analysis
Techniques: Tools for Design and Evaluation. Human-Computer
Interaction Institute Technical Report CMU-HCII-94-106 (1994).
An overview of the GOMS family of models, including KLM, GOMS,
CMN-GOMS, NGOMSL, and CPM-GOMS. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
John, B. E. & Kieras, D. E. "Using GOMS for User
Interface Design and Evaluation: Which Technique?"
ACM
Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction Vol. 3.4
(1996): 287-319. Provides guidance about which GOMS variant to
use to meet different design goals. [View or Download: From
Source / Local
Copy]
John, B., Vera, A., Matessa, M., Freed, M., &
Remington, R. "Automating CPM-GOMS." In Proceeding
of CHI 2002, Minneapolis, MN: April 2002. A process for
automatically generating CPM-GOMS models from a hierarchical
task decomposition in Apex is described. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]
|
| |
|
5. |
CAT (Cognitive Analysis Tool)
Dr.
Kent E. Williams Home Page. The CAT-HCI software and
manuals are available for download.
Baumeister, L. K., John, B. E., & Byrne, Michael D. A
Comparison of Tools for Building GOMS Models. In Proceedings
of CHI 2000 ( April 2000). QGOMS, CAT-HCI, and GLEAN3 are
compared.
Voigt, J. R. Evaluating a Computerized Aid for
Conducting a Cognitive Task Analysis. Master of Science
Thesis, University of Central Florida. (2000). CAT-HCI is used
to analyze tank command and control. [View or Download:
Local
Copy]
Williams, K. E. An Automated Aid for Modeling
Human-Computer Interaction. In Chipman, Shalin & Schraagen,
Eds. Cognitive Task Analysis. New Jersey: Lawrence
Erlbaum, 2000. 165-180.
|
| |
|
Integrated
Cognitive Architectures
Byrne, M. D. Cognitive Architecture. An introduction
to modeling cognition with Integrated Cognitive Architectures. [View or Download:
From
Source / Local
Copy]< | |